top of page

Thinking in Landscapes: Reimagining Systems Change

vikarainstitute
4 days ago
4 min read

Conversations on systems change are often still rooted in a mechanistic worldview, where progress is viewed as a binary: a change either occurred or it did not. This "machine" metaphor is fundamentally ill-suited for understanding, monitoring, or navigating the evolution of complex social systems. In reality, systems evolve through a messy interplay of competing forces and factors. This push and pull often creates a dynamic equilibrium - a set of "guardrails" - that defines dominant patterns and directs societal evolution. However, these patterns are frequently misinterpreted as evidence of a static or predictable environment.  This perception of systems as knowable and "fixable" has deeply influenced international development. Many donor investments are predicated on the idea that a project can impose predefined results onto a system. This misalignment between development frameworks and the messy realities of complex social systems is largely driven by the need to justify investments through traditional accountability. While accountability is vital, we must completely rethink how we ensure effective stewardship and redefine what a successful "return on investment" actually means in a systemic context.

 

To embrace complexity, practitioners must first accept that systems are constantly evolving, guided by deep-seated mental models and cultural norms. Transformative change only emerges when these "slow-moving variables" shift, redirecting the system’s trajectory. Much like the distinction between weather and climate, where individual weather events are volatile and do not necessarily reflect long-term trends, systems change is about cumulative patterns. Just as greenhouse gases act as a foundational guardrail for our climate, mindsets and norms serve as the guardrails for social systems. Interpreting a single event as a definitive systemic shift is as invalid as citing a snowstorm as evidence against global warming. Effective systems thinking must focus on how these landscapes evolve over time and how we can interpret their directional shifts.


A directional shift is not necessarily progress. Systems can evolve toward arrangements that are more exclusionary, concentrated or harmful as well as toward arrangements that expand people's opportunities and capacities. Landscape thinking therefore requires two distinct questions: How is the system changing? and What are the consequences of that change, and for whom?

 

Vikara has been researching and testing methods to interpret and monitor these evolutionary directions. A powerful framework for this is the "fitness landscape." In this metaphor, the combination of current conditions, forces, and factors creates a terrain of mountains and valleys, making certain behaviors easier or harder to adopt. Path dependency, for instance, can be visualized as a clear, well-trodden pathway that is perceived as favorable by local actors. In such landscapes, the social or economic costs of pushing against established norms are high, leaving the system "stuck" on its current path.


Thinking in landscapes helps practitioners discern the signal from the noise. By focusing on the net effect of social barriers, gender roles, and cultural norms, we can understand the guardrails that frame a system's direction. This approach empowers practitioners in four key ways:

  1. Shifting from Imposing Change to Supporting Local Processes: The most critical shift in "MSD 2.0" is moving away from the belief that projects can drive systemic change. Durable outcomes like inclusivity, fairness, and transparency must emerge from within the system. Transformation occurs when the landscape itself shifts - turning former "mountains" into accessible pathways.

  2. Distinguishing Volatility from Transformation: A historical focus on superficial results often leads to tracking changes that are easily reversed. Landscape thinking helps practitioners identify shifts that actually alter the terrain. For example, a seasonal increase in input sales to women is a superficial change; a systemic shift would involve navigating the foundational gender norms that historically prevented such access. 

  3. Designing Interventions that Fit and Leverage Local Dynamics: Donor influence can disrupt a system temporarily, but once that pressure is removed, the old guardrails usually pull the system back to its status quo. To be truly catalytic, projects must move away from rigid, preconceived targets. Instead, they should focus on a process of listening, learning, and adapting (probe-learn-adapt) to identify and amplify "attractors" - changes that resonate locally and trigger positive knock-on effects.

  4. Adapting to Catalyze Deeper Shifts: To affect the fundamental features of a landscape, practitioners must be attuned to local signals. For practitioners, the initial intervention or probe is only a starting point. From that starting point, practitioners should be interpreting whether the initial probe is resonating.  If it does resonate, practitioners should focus on where new opportunities or points of leverage are emerging that should inform adaptations that can support more foundational shifts in the system’s guardrails.  Essentially interventions should evolve from bounded, one-off activities to a process of probing, learning, and adapting that support and catalyze internal change processes leading to a shift in the direction toward greater inclusivity, fairness, transparency, etc. 


In an increasingly uncertain world where vulnerability is rising, practitioners and donors must embrace complex realities to ensure investments are truly catalytic. Thinking in landscapes provides a vital lens for this engagement, though much remains to be explored. The Market Systems Symposium 2026 in Cape Town, South Africa provided an opportunity to deepen these conversations, and Vikara looks forward to building on this momentum as we continue exploring new approaches to understanding and catalyzing systemic change.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page